Gaerne Eskimo

Price Paid:  $160.00 at eBay

Favorite Ride:
Chicago Lakefront at Dawn

Bike Setup:
Insofar as it matters, a Cervelo R3 with Shimano SPD-M540 pedals (deal with it.:))

Summary:
Bought these boots in desperation after miserable attempts to make multiple layers of socks and various booties work. What a relief! They are Italian, so the initial fit is a bit tight, but there's a little give in them and after a couple of rides they fit perfectly. I bought my normal shoe size and wear them with a pair of "normal" cycling socks and sealskins without difficulty. There is still room for a thicker pair of thermal type socks and I will try that when I get round to buying a pair. They are wonderful cold weather boots but not superhuman in their abilities. With my present set up I can ride them all day at 32F/0C but at 25F/-3C my feet start to get chilly at the two hour mark and are pretty uncomfortable by three: not a problem for me as it's very unlikely I would ride more than three hours at that temperature. Where they surprised me though was in wet weather: they've kept my feet bone dry in some dreadfully wet conditions. All in all, I'm delighted with them. If you're a masochistic Minnesotan or live in Scandinavia and insist in riding routinely in 20F/-5C weather, I'd think twice about purchasing them but otherwise I recommend them wholeheartedly.

Strengths:
They work! They keep your feet warm in the cold and dry in the wet.

Weaknesses:
I have doubts that they can handle temperatures much below 25F/-3C for extended periods of time.

Similar Products Used:
None. I will never use booties again!

Price Paid:  $159.00 at biketiresdirect.com

Favorite Ride:
My Girlfriend

Bike Setup:
Schwinn Fastback Pro, it's my commuter and my weekend ride.

Summary:
These shoes are great. It takes a little bit of time to get used to how these shoes lace up, and how tight to make them, but once you get an idea of how tight is tight enough, they are so comfortable. There are no hot spots, don't make my feet go to sleep, etc. I don't think about my feet when I wear these, and regardless of the weather, my feet are warm and dry. I have commuted all winter in these shoes, and now I've bought some Gaerne summer shoes, cause I can't go back to my Shimano's after wearing these.

Strengths:
Completely waterproof
Warm
Very comfortable
Price

Weaknesses:
Look a little "Italian", but I actually like that, it's different.

Similar Products Used:
Booties and summer shoes. No comparison.