Review Options:
Sorted by Latest Review | Sort by Best Rating |
|
Reviews 1 - 3 (3 Reviews Total)
| |
User Reviews
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
johnlisa5135
a Recreational Rider
from Date Reviewed: October 31, 2009
Strengths: Look very stylish. Better than the OEM Shimano RS-10 on my Cervelo RS!Weaknesses: Bit heavy at 1800GBottom Line: They are fine wheels for the style of riding my wife and I do. I'll elaborate after a few more miles. Came as standard wheelset on the bike. Very forgiving with the 25mm Specialized tires.
Favorite Ride: The one I'm on
Purchased At: ebay
Similar Products Used: Shimano RS-10, Bontrager Race, Race Lite, Mavic Ksyrium SL
Bike Setup: 2009 Specialized Roubaix Expert Compact. Everything standard OEM. (Saddle leaving soon!)
Overall Rating: Value Rating:
Submitted by
DBX
a Road Racer
from Date Reviewed: September 25, 2009
Strengths: Value when on sale (note my value rating is a compromise between 5+ for what I paid and about 3- at list).
A revelation compared to the junk you'll likely get as standard on a $1,500 bike (they always cheap out on wheels more than anything else). Do yourself a favor, once you've got a saddle that fits, if you only do one more upgrade ever, do the wheels.
Sturdy for a height/weight proportionate rider
Very good rear wheel design with offset rim
Attractive lookWeaknesses: Question marks on bearings
Non-standard spokes are difficult to service and replace
Bottom Line: At the price I paid -- a half-off sale with another coupon stacked on that -- these wheels were excellent value, indeed untouchable by anything else, and my only regret was not having the storage space to buy a second set. They're not quite worth the $600 list price, though.
This is a solid wheelset. Overall, the rims are very well designed, and durable. They have survived potholes and kerb mountings with only minimal truing, and unlike cheaper and flexier Shimano wheelsets like the R540 they do not recoil violently over potholes or act like rubber bands when cornering. However, Shimano has a -- let's be polite here -- idiosyncratic approach to spokes, and servicing these wheels will be a pain should you break one. Even finding a mechanic who's happy working on hub-mounted nipples as opposed to rim mounted is going to be a little tricky.
The cheaper Shimano wheelsets are very flexy, and frankly dangerous in cornering on a downhill. These are reassuringly solid and they will give you a safer and more controllable and smoother ride over broken pavement.
I'd avoid them if you're heavy. I'm 171 pounds but I'd be nervous about hitting potholes and at least one major kerb mounting like I have if I were, say, 200 pounds. Even at 171 pounds a two inch kerb made a nasty crunching noise. These are a low spoke count wheel, 16 front and 20 rear, and even with the outstanding offset design of the rear rim, putting a 200 pound or more rider is asking a bit much of them.
I second the previous reviewer about the hub bearings. Mine aren't nearly as bad as he describes his, but it's only a matter of time for the front bearings which don't spin that smoothly anymore and it's not as though I have a huge amount of mileage
Look out for these wheels on sale (I figure anything at $450 or below is fair), or alternatively look at a set of Eastons or go a nice, practical, light-ish aluminum-rimmed wheel in whatever brand is sponsored and discounted by your bike club if applicable.
Favorite Ride: Any long paved trail
Price Paid:
$230.00
Purchased At: Performance sale
Similar Products Used: Shimano R540 (extensively) -- much too flexy for anything more than recreational riding
Test rides of various stock wheels, most of them even more wobbly than the R540.
Bike Setup: Cannondale Synapse alloy, 105-10 drivetrain, compact 50/34 crank.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
ivan in tacoma
a Commuter
from Date Reviewed: February 11, 2009
Strengths: good looks and toughness. rear hub is nice and smooth. aerodynamic.Weaknesses: quality control. the set is heavy. i expected better from shimano....though they are working on the 6700 ultegra i hope they hurry up.Bottom Line: they are slightly better than the wh-600 they look really good. the rear hub spins well and so does the cassette the front wheel also is desent. though i find the quality to be fair the durability is good iam a fatty at 225. they hold me well enough but heres the bad. make sure when you buy them to check the bearings. mine the front hub was to tight to even spin. i replaced the bearings and wow! like dura ace! theyre heavy too but tough. for the price i think you could get better.
Favorite Ride: roubaix
Price Paid:
$3700.00
Purchased At: earth
Similar Products Used: mavic SL3 in my book the best wheel set ive ever known.
Bike Setup: ultegra and roubaix. yummy!
|
Reviews 1 - 3 (3 Reviews Total)
| |
Review Options:
Sorted by Latest Review | Sort by Best Rating |
