Road Bike, Cycling Forums banner

Schwinn Madison Pro Review

17K views 33 replies 30 participants last post by  Tommy_P.  
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
Image


Schwinn Madison Pro Review - By Thien Dinh
  • Schwinn Custom Track Frame w/ N'Gauged Double Butted Cro-Moly Main Tubes & N'Gauged Track Fork w/ Brazed Crown
  • 48x18t Drivetrain w/ Flip-Flop Fixed/Freewheel Hub, Truvativ Touro Track Cranks
  • Formula Hubs & Alex Semi-Aero Rims, Schwalbe Lugano Sport 23c Tires
  • Alloy 31.8 Bar & Stem
  • MSRP - $569

Intro...

The Schwinn Madison is quite simply one of the more exciting bikes we've tested recently. Not because it introduces some sort of new nano-carbon-best of the breed technology… Not because it's an uber light race bike that guarantees race results… and definitely not because it sports a brand new groupset that makes shifting better, faster, or stronger (it doesn't shift at all!). It's the opposite of all that, and that's why it's so exciting! It's simply simple.

page_turner.jpg



madison003sm.jpg


Schwinn's Madison is a moderately low cost entry into the world of fixed gear and single speed fun. A complete bike that includes a track inspired geometry frame (double butted Cro-Moly), with an "N'Gauged" straight track fork complete with brazed crown. A 48 tooth chainring Truvativ Touro Track Crank paired with a 18t cog or 18t ACS freewheel keep things moving along briskly. The all steel frameset runs on a pair of semi aero rims laced to standard track fare Formula hubs. Wrapped in Schwalbe Lugano Sport tires, the setup makes for a solid ride. Braking comes via a set of Tektro 510A dual pivot calipers, standard for a bike in this price range. The rest of the components, we'll just mention are standard entry level parts, matching the rest of the bike.

The complete package comes in at a grand total weight of ~22.5 pounds according to our scale. Maybe not your first choice to go hit up the local climb to try to best your PR, but plenty of bike to roll around town in style.

page_turner.jpg



madison002sm.jpg


How does it ride…
To be honest, when we first received this bike, I was a little trepid about riding it fixed. So I ran it singlespeed for much of the first few weeks, which is one of the convenient features of the Madison. The inclusion of a very convenient flip flop hub, on one side, a fixed cog, on the other side an ACS maindrive freewheel. Very helpful for the timid first time fixed gear rider like myself. I figured once I got the bike dialed in fit wise, I'd give fixed a go… what would be the harm? If I didn't like fixed, I'd just go back to the tried and friendly freewheel and keep it single speed. . I used the Madison for all sorts of riding - runs to the coffee shop, heading downtown to the local bookstore, and just about anytime I wanted an excuse to go out for a spin.

The Madison's ride is quite forgiving. The steel frame albeit, budget, did very well to communicate road feel, it could even be described as a tad bit springy. The geometry of the Madison is track inspired, with a short wheelbase of only 968mm and 72.5 degree head angle, the overall feel of the bike is quick and maneuverable. The included Selle San Marco saddle was light, but like most saddles YMMV. The traditional 32 spoke wheelset was strong and stood up to the varied terrain we took the Madison out on. Once you're up to speed, the weight of the bike doesn't even enter your mind, even the simple drivetrain is near silent, just the whistling of the wind going by is all that one notices.

madison005sm.jpg


page_turner.jpg



Formula TH-51 Hub

Fixed on the left, Freewheel on the right

When the rear wheel was flipped to the fixed side, it took only a few rides to understand why so many have caught the fixed gear bug. There's a new dimension of riding that is introduced, a challenge even. But like many things on the bike, it just takes time to improve and eventually it becomes very natural. When riding fixed you feel an extra connection to the bike and your riding experience is definitely quite different from geared biking. Not only are you directly attached to the drivetrain, meaning going and stopping are now controlled from the drivetrain, but moderately easy hills you thought nothing of on your geared bike, become small challenges. If you don't already have good cadence and pedal stroke, you soon will! Training takes on a whole new meaning, because now you can't be tempted to drop down to an easier gear on that climb, you HAVE to grind it out. In the long run, this will definitely make you a better rider, stronger, faster, yeah, all of that.

Truvativ Touro Track crank 170mm w/ 48T chainring


page_turner.jpg



madison012sm.jpg

Selle San Marco Ponza

madison010sm.jpg

Tektro 510A rear caliper

madison014sm.jpg

Tektro 510A front caliper

page_turner.jpg



madison004sm.jpg

Formula TH-50 (front) (Formula TH-51 rear)

madison007sm.jpg

High flanges

madison009sm.jpg

Jalco DRX2000 Rims...

page_turner.jpg



madison015sm.jpg

Matching bar and stem...

madison016sm.jpg

Cane Creek headset...

madison006sm.jpg

Schwinn N'Gauged Track fork w/ brazed crown construction and 28.6mm ovalised legs

page_turner.jpg



2008 Schwinn Madison


Conclusion
The Schwinn Madison is definitely an appealing bike… the retro paint job (which we give two thumbs up to) brings us back to yesteryear, when things were "simple". The gearing and setup are "simple". The low cost of this complete turnkey fixie/SS is "simple" to justify. The inclusion of bottle mounts as well as fender mounts makes the Madsion a prime candidate to be used as a commuter. We liked the Madison, SS or fixed, and recommending it be added to any stable is simple.

Strengths
  • Simple turnkey solution to singlespeed/Fixed fun
  • All around solid bike for commuting, switching up the training, or all out fun to ride around town.
  • Low price, low upkeep, low maintenance…
  • Chrome accents - who doesn't like chrome right?
Weaknesses
  • Weight
  • Zip ties (look out of place, not an issue if you don't run a rear brake)
Value:
Four Stars


Overall:
Four Stars
 

Attachments

#8 ·
The Madison is an OK Bike, and I've seen plenty of them around. However, after lots of research, I bought a bianchi San Jose. Single speed, horizontal drops, and rack/fender mounts, for about the same price. I road it all year round' thru the winter with skinny tires and never had a problem. BTW, I live in Madison, WI...
 
#9 ·
I hope these are strong frames if there going for the look of my 1980 Schwinn Voyageur or the other ones with the similiar look just below the Paramounts from the 70's and 80's.Who makes the frames ?? Probably not the good makers of the original ones from the 70's and 80's from Japan.No lugs so maybe that helps to make them affordable.Hope there on par with the Surlys at least with the steel.
 
#16 ·
I bought a 2007 Madison (slightly tighter geometry, but roughly the same otherwise) when it first came out, and I'm still very happy with it as my daily ride. I've replaced a lot of the components by now, of course, as I had money to burn, but the stock components are decent. Replacing the stem, seatpost, and bars along with removing the rear brake made a good difference weight-wise. I beg to differ with "thejerk" -- all these Taiwanese-made off the peg track bikes from Schwinn, Bianchi, Masi, Surly, IRO, et al. are using the same generic 4130 cro-moly. (Those that are not are using Reynolds 520, which is essentially the same thing.) Ride-wise, I couldn't notice a difference between it and friends' Pistas, Kilo TTs, Fuji Tracks, and the like. Definitely rides nicer than the Langster I rode around for a few blocks, too.

BTW, the Cutter is going to be made using hi-tensile steel to compete directly with low-priced bikes like the SE Lager Draft, etc. It's probably going to weigh a good bit more, as a result. Not that I haven't thought about picking one up as a trick/polo bike...
 
#17 ·
I bought this bike in July, and love it. I picked it up on sale, paid $365 for it. Agree that components need upgrades (I've replaced brakes, seatpost, tires, added clipless pedals, and switched rear cog to 16t), but it is a blast to ride. I use it as a daily commuter, as well as for longer rides just for the fun of it. It is a tad heavy, but even when climbing it never really feels it. The steel does a good job of taking the sting out of rough roads. Overall a great bike for the money.
 
#19 ·
I'll stick to my 1985 Nishiki 12-speed, but this is a nice late model SS (nee 'track bike', I hate that term since less than 1% of these will ever be ridden on a track).

the flip hub is a sweet concept, and I'm not sure why more SS road bikes don't come with one. I don't understand why every road bike has to be yellow. to me, this is one of the best (and I normally hate powder blue, but the silver really makes it happen). I enjoy multiple gears too much, but if I had to pick a single, this is one I'd strongly consider. agree with the bloke who said all these generic frames are the same. yes they SHOULD be lighter than they are, but that's the cost of using such large diameter tubing these days. if you're going to go with a new bike and want SS, you should be giving this a look.
 
#21 ·
I had a 1975 Schwinn Continental that I had fixed. It was nice, but rode like a 30 year old bike with lots of creaks. I sold the old Schwinn and picked up the 2008 Madison. I love this bike and it provides a solid but light ride through Boston each day. I jumped on the 2008 for the color scheme, and it was a lot cheaper than the 2009. I plan on updating a few things, but I'm very happy with this ride.

If you're interested in the Madison, it's at least worth a test ride.
 
#22 ·
i rode a white 2007 for 2 years.... they are heavy cuz of the cheap parts. buy the bike for the frame sell all the cheap parts to someone just getting into \fixie\ riding... and put nice cranks.wheels.etc on it. it treated me well. i actually threw it around quite a bit before it got stolen last week. no cracks or anything. good frame. strong.
 
#23 ·
As "brian s" says, I like gears too much, and I'm less than a year away from being 60...but I bought one anyway and although I'm going to configure the bike as a "Social Security" model (42t chainring, leave both brakes mounted), I will ride it. Once I'm a little more comfortable on the frame, I'll flip the hub and be "the old man living dangerously". Mine is yellow, put on cow horn bars and rewrapped with yellow/black cork tape and think it came out n-i-c-e. Be safe, they're not looking out for us.
 
#24 ·
I raced one of the old, late 70's, Schwinn Madison's to many top placings on the track. It did not have rack mounts, brakes, or any other needless accessories. Just straight Columbus SL tubes and Suntour Superbe Pro crankset and wheels. I can't believe I every parted with that bike. For anyone unhappy with the "new" Madison, go to your local velodromo and check out the used bike listings.