bill said:
You believe, I'm guessing, that the wisdom behind what you're saying is self-evident, and maybe it is, but could you elaborate?
This is what I've got. I've gone down hard maybe three times in memory. I guess four. Once, at about 28 mph, I lost a frame and some skin but nothing much else happened, once I got a pretty vicious hip pointer from landing square on my left hip, once at 35 on a ripping downhill and barely lost skin, and I do mean barely, nothing else, and once at about 25-30, and I broke my pelvis in two places and my sacrum in one.
I also have gone down here and there without any injury.
I can't think of any instance when additional flexibility might have helped. And I'm 47 y/o and have never stretched.
In fact, as I remember the article, it talked about possible increased risk of injury from increased flexibility -- the looser ligaments just don't hold your joints together as solidly, so that you could end up more easily hyper-extending or flexing. I know a former dancer, and she has all KINDS of problems in her joints. She insists on maintaining her flexibility, but, if you ask me, all she's doing is continually inflaming her joints, without the corresponding musculature that likely used to hold her together. She's like 27 y/o, and she's a mess in that department.
Can I back up what I've heard about accidents? Not with anything more than just that I've read about it. So far, all I've heard from your argument is that because you've never suffered from the fact that you've never stretched, you don't see why anybody would benefit from it. Going against that logic is kind of like trying to prove a negative, which you can't really do. All we pro-flexibility folk have got is a large body of reading, research and practical clinical experience that suggests maintaining your flexibility is good for you, and as far as I know, one article (and you and your one article, which may be the same one) that says it may not be.
As to the article's assertion that there's an increased risk of derangement, I'd again point to the fact that they may have been studying hypermobility. If your muscles don't react or feel stressed when your joints are at their limits, then there's a some kind if increased risk to the joints, sure. I don't think you'd find that in people whose flexibility is within more normal, theoretically optimal, ranges.
Your dancer friend may just have crappy joints--it's common enough, and it's also common for joints that never bothered you before to become very painful as you age (I hit a wall at 23 and was no longer able to run because of my ankles). Poor stretching technique can also be very harmful, as can poor running, cycling, dancing or weightlifting technique. I've also read that an over-emphasis on stretching and hypermobility in kids can result in some bad things--probably your friend has been doing her thing since she was really young, and never knew a time she wasn't able to do a full split (a common skill for little girls). I don't see much reason to put her problems down to flexibility--could be any number of things.
Do you run? I know three people right now who've had to give up running because their hamstrings are so tight they get knee problems when they run (all just nearing 40--no surprise there). None of them can touch their toes, or even get close. Most of them can't pull their knees toward their chest to get their hips bent more than 90 degrees, either.
I won't get into the whole issue of quitting running instead of developing a little flexibility, but this points to the idea that a certain level of flexibility is natural and reasonable and good for you, especially in athletic endeavors.
Could be wrong, but so far I don't have any problems that I can say were caused or aggravated by flexibility, but I can think of a couple of situations where flexbility/stretching has helped me avoid or recover more quickly from injury.
Finally, you do realize, don't you, that you may be one of those people who just HAS a certain amount of flexibilty without working to maintain it. If you've never stretched, you may not even know. Your previous posts don't indicate your actual level of flexibility.