Road Bike, Cycling Forums banner
1 - 20 of 60 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
159 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I'm currently looking to replace my current road bike with a road bike (disc) that can accomidate close to 40mm tires; if there are any suggestions out there please shout them out.

Tricky part is I want whatever I go with to be able to be both comfortable for hours upon hours on gravel and (after some changes to the gearing/rubber) be able to hold it's own in a crit/road race. Open UP and 3T Exploro are the obvious answers but seriously pricy, Foundry Overland and Santa Cruz Stigmata have my interest right now too and are in the lead. They both look like a winners in my mind.. So if anyone has either of these and pushes them on and off the road I'm interested in hearing how you like them.

I expect with disc brakes to continue to be pushed hard by bike manufacturers and there will be a lot more options that would fit this niche soon.. I'm a big guy 6'3'' so I'm not one that really sweats the fact my bike could be a pound or two heavier than the next guys. I've accepted the fact that I'll have to slam the stem on whatever frame I get as all the options apart from the 3T are pretty relaxed...
 

·
Adorable Furry Hombre
Joined
·
30,963 Posts
I'm currently looking to replace my current road bike with a road bike (disc) that can accomidate close to 40mm tires; if there are any suggestions out there please shout them out.

Tricky part is I want whatever I go with to be able to be both comfortable for hours upon hours on gravel and (after some changes to the gearing/rubber) be able to hold it's own in a crit/road race. Open UP and 3T Exploro are the obvious answers but seriously pricy, Foundry Overland and Santa Cruz Stigmata have my interest right now too and are in the lead. They both look like a winners in my mind.. So if anyone has either of these and pushes them on and off the road I'm interested in hearing how you like them.

I expect with disc brakes to continue to be pushed hard by bike manufacturers and there will be a lot more options that would fit this niche soon.. I'm a big guy 6'3'' so I'm not one that really sweats the fact my bike could be a pound or two heavier than the next guys. I've accepted the fact that I'll have to slam the stem on whatever frame I get as all the options apart from the 3T are pretty relaxed...
Gravel and crit riding are two fairly diametrically opposed need sets.

I'd keep your road bike and get a dedicated gravel/off-road steed of which there are many. The Foundry bikes are nice, Foundry is a Salsa branding-and can be purchased locally at any QBP-supplied LBS in your area.


Doing so would also open up your choices substantially.
 

·
Forever a Student
Joined
·
4,963 Posts
Gravel: Long wheel base, long chainstays, low bottom bracket, slack angles.

Crit: Short wheelbase, short chainstays, high bottom bracket, sharp angles.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
960 Posts
Not sure you can get one bike to do everything, but disc brakes will let you go with 650B wheels which will let you go beyond stated spec on most road bikes. 700 wheels for faster riding, and 650B wide tires for gravel

I have converted an old road frame over to 650B, and I can use 38's. With 700s 28s were the largest I could run
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
159 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,658 Posts
Look into custom steel, or ti if you budget allows. You said you're a big guy so the extra pound or so shouldn't matter in exchange for being able to get exactly what you want for a decent price.

It's true that gravel bikes and crit bikes are quite different. But really racing an aggressive (by gravel bike standards) gravel bike in a crit wouldn't be a problem per se. Less than idea but your speed will be all about the tires you put on it so you'd do fine. I've raced a few crits on my gravel bike. No big deal.
The other way around, however, is less feasible. A crit bike could get to squirrely in soft gravel.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
159 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
Gravel and crit riding are two fairly diametrically opposed need sets.

I'd keep your road bike and get a dedicated gravel/off-road steed of which there are many. The Foundry bikes are nice, Foundry is a Salsa branding-and can be purchased locally at any QBP-supplied LBS in your area.


Doing so would also open up your choices substantially.
I guess I would lean much more towards road races than to crits (they are just more frequent).. It would open up my choices but I don't really have the budget to spring for a road bike that would only get used 5-10 times per year..
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,025 Posts
Gravel: Long wheel base, long chainstays, low bottom bracket, slack angles.

Crit: Short wheelbase, short chainstays, high bottom bracket, sharp angles.
Yeah, very different requirements. The mega-buck (and bizarre to me) 3T Exploro might work as it's racy but has large tire clearance. I'd recommend getting an inexpensive crit racer and an inexpensive gravel bike. Both of these disciplines are crash-prone and you don't want to ride something you can't afford to trash.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,658 Posts
Yeah, very different requirements. The mega-buck (and bizarre to me) 3T Exploro might work as it's racy but has large tire clearance. I'd recommend getting an inexpensive crit racer and an inexpensive gravel bike. Both of these disciplines are crash-prone and you don't want to ride something you can't afford to trash.
Two bikes is a good idea because changing tires and gearing all the time would be a pain......but I'm going to suggest that this business of different angles ect, while true, is being way overstatated. One could do just fine road racing and gravel riding the same frame.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
159 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
Two bikes is a good idea because changing tires and gearing all the time would be a pain......but I'm going to suggest that this business of different angles ect, while true, is being way overstatated. One could do just fine road racing and gravel riding the same frame.
I'll be honest, I almost exclusively ride road/pavement and that won't change drastically with a new bike so there wouldn't be a great deal of hassle in changing gearing/tires around often. Leaning towards the Santa Cruz Stigmata as it is on par in terms of price of the Foundry and potentially just as light as my current road bike.
Ideally Trek comes out with a new domane with crazy clearance on it and I can just pick that up...
 

·
Bianchi-Campagnolo
Joined
·
3,902 Posts
The caad 12 would be perfect with just a little more tire clearance, but then Cannondale would have a lot of trouble selling a slate..
The Slate is more like a Synapse with 650B fat tires and a shock fork.
 

·
Banned Sock Puppet
Joined
·
14,450 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
647 Posts
They would be absolutely perfect with just a little more clearance. Last I heard they really only fit up to 28mm tires.
I have a friend who just got the SLR 6 Disc and it came stock with 32 road slick. It should fit a 33 CX tire with decent room. I'd suggest looking at one in person if you get a chance.
Domane SLR 6 Disc | Trek Bikes

Also, not the best name, but the new DB Haanjo looks sweet.
Diamondback Bicycles - Bikes - Road - Alternative Road - Haanjo - Haanjo Trail Carbon
 

·
Banned Sock Puppet
Joined
·
14,450 Posts
That is pretty close to what I'm looking for, Stigmatas geometry looks slightly better for racing on the road. Thanks for bringing it in I'll look at it more for sure.
If you are looking for a more aggressive geometry, you may want to look at some cyclocross bikes. Though I don't know if any of those can fit 40c tires.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
71 Posts
I can't commit on which frame is the best all a rounder, but I sold my road bike a year and half ago and have been riding my Specialized Crux w/disc for everything and it's a great do it all bike (gravel, road (endurance and racing), and cx). I bought a nice set of wheels for the road (ENVE 5.6s) and with those, I have no problem hanging with the fast guys. Its not the ideal geometry for serious road riding or racing crits but I do both no problem and the bike is super comfortable on long distance road rides.

Point is, save some of your budget for a nice set of aero wheels and you'll be very happy you did when riding and racing on the road. Nice wheels will make a much bigger difference on the road than a cm difference in geometry.
 

·
Adorable Furry Hombre
Joined
·
30,963 Posts
I guess I would lean much more towards road races than to crits (they are just more frequent).. It would open up my choices but I don't really have the budget to spring for a road bike that would only get used 5-10 times per year..
Since you're set on a do-it-all bike....Consider Rodeo Labs Flaanimal (in steel or Ti)

Flaanimal 3.0 Adventure Bike. specification preview - Rodeo Adventure Labs, LLCRodeo Adventure Labs, LLC


I'm lining up to build one this spring for a non-paved surface bike. It is the only real many-role frameset on the market, the adjustable dropouts will come in handy for you in allowing you to shallow or deepen the wheelbase, depending on surface.
 
1 - 20 of 60 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top