Road Bike, Cycling Forums banner

I'm in ur crit crashing ur Cat4's

3809 Views 43 Replies 21 Participants Last post by  mepshteyn
The Twilight Criterium in Boise, ID. I was in the Cat4/5 class and it was a 45 min. race. It was freaking hot!!! About 95 degrees. I vowed to myself to work harder than last week's crit. Last week I thought I was really working hard because I was at 105-107% of LTHR most of the time. Today I would have been very happy to have my HR at 107%. It was always around 110% and I saw it at 113% a few times.

Little mini breaks would try to start but they never got more than a ten yard or so gap and when they would start to go I would work my way up through the field and get on the tail end of them. Then I figured out I could hide in the middle of the group and basically coast down the whole front straight. After a few laps of that I got some legs back and with six laps to go I moved up the inside of the pack down the front straight into the #1 spot just as we got to the first corner. I held my line in the corner but I guess the guy in the #2 spot didn't expect me to be there because he dove into the corner and right into my back wheel. I heard things breaking (some of my spokes) and then a big crash (two guys went down). I stayed up but my wheel was rubbing my frame and slowing me down. I was just coasting to a stop and the peloton is freaking out on me - Hello, I can't go - I just kept a straight line until they all went around me. There was less than 8 laps left so I couldn't get a wheel and a free lap so I was done.

The thing that sucked was that the guy that hit me was the former Cat3 guy I ride with back home. Last week when he said that he had reclassified to Cat4 and that we would be in the same class in our crit he said "Don't crash me." I feel really bad. He broke his collar bone. I don't think I did anything wrong. I was ahead of him and holding my line and he ran into my back wheel but I've been pretty bummed out about it all evening.
See less See more
21 - 40 of 44 Posts
cxwrench said:
describe a "typical" crash...given what we know
Guys collide and fall down. Blame is fuzzy. It's racing.

I'm always reminded of a basic concept taught to aviators and drivers: "see and avoid"

BMX, call the guy and make sure he's ok, hear his side of the story, talk it out. You 2 were there, we weren't.

But don't obsess over it; crit racing is a squirrelly business.
the guy is obviously a beginner...he's posting about it because he wants input, and that's what the forum is for. his competitor ended up on the ground w/ broken bones. if he can learn from this and it means something like this won't happen to him and maybe some other folks here, it's damn well worth 'obsessing' a bit.
cxwrench said:
the guy is obviously a beginner...he's posting about it because he wants input, and that's what the forum is for. his competitor ended up on the ground w/ broken bones. if he can learn from this and it means something like this won't happen to him and maybe some other folks here, it's damn well worth 'obsessing' a bit.
Seems to me you're the one doing the obsessing.

You and I were not there... we can only spout generalities. IMO we have no useful advice to offer, other than "talk it over and learn what you can"
Its so easy to be a Dbag on the interweb forums. That being said bmx has always been very respectful and seems like he's always trying to learn. I'm a first year racer and many of bmx's questions have been the same ones I have. BMX, if your online demeanor is any indication of who you are as a person then I'm sure your friend will hold no grudges regardless of who is at fault.

But look at the bright side. You may have given him a great battle story!
I'm pretty much a [email protected] :)
When you write him that letter, be sure to include a bill for the wheel repair.
So I don't become one of those cat 4's causing crashes, can someone explain apexes to me?

I know on my first race I lost tons of time in corners, especially on one Chicane.
BMX I'm late to this thread, but maybe an anecdote will make you feel better.

The second road race I ever did in my life, my teammate and I were about 20 miles in, attempting to bridge up to a breakaway, and we were both hauling buckets. I was desperately clinging to her wheel hoping not to get shelled, and overlapping it a bit when she stood up and moved her bike over prolly 8" -- swept my front wheel right out from under me, and I skidded across the nasty sharp chipseal at 25+ mph. Tore my entire right side off, down to the bone in a couple places. I was so pissed off (mostly at myself) that I grabbed my bike out of the ditch and chased for a young eternity and eventually caught back on to the front.

I looked about like Jens did yesterday at the finish line, bleeding profusely, with most of my arse end hanging out of my (formerly brand new, expensive) shorts. Rode past our coach and he was like OMG ARE YOU OKAY and I was like NO!!!!! (and maybe some cuss words).

I immediately went to my teammate to apologize for making such a n00b mistake like that, and before I could even get a word in, she apologized profusely for sweeping my wheel when she stood up. She'd made the break and won the race (which was our goal, and I was bridging with her to give her support), but she thought she was in the wrong.

The point I'm trying to make here, is that it takes 2 to tango. BOTH of us made mistakes that day, and bike races are dangerous and accidents do happen. That's bike racing.

I still have a big thick keloid scar on my right shoulder, 24 seasons later, just to remind me of that. All the other ones have faded.

That same teammate and I went on to win several other races over the next 3 seasons, and we are still good friends to this day, albiet time and distance means we mostly only communicate through Facebook these days.

So yes, learn something from it, and I'm glad you're taking accountability for it, but the only way forward is through, and the only way to be a better bike racer is to keep doing bike races. Crashes just happen. Go out with some good riders and learn roadie skills, and yea it sucks to crash out a buddy, but just talk to him, ask him if he's okay, and tell him you're sorry it happened.
See less See more
i'm not slamming bmx in any way, i think it's great he's trying to figure out what happened and how to handle the situation, which is a lot more than most people would do. most guys wouldn't even think it was worth thinking about and move on. i'm sure he'll learn from the situation and be a better rider for it. most of this discussion will benefit other racers who may or may not have had a similar incident.

as for apex...
it's the point in the corner where you are furthest to the 'inside' of the turn...the point furthest to the outside where you start your turn is the 'turn-in point' and the point furthest to the outside on the exit would be called 'track-out' in car racing...not sure anyone calls it anything other than the 'curb' in bike racing. an 'late' apex is more preferable to an 'early' apex as it will generally leave you w/ room on the exit of a corner. if you 'early' apex, you can run out of room on the exit...if you're the one leading into a corner, you can pick the line and determine where the apex will be.
See less See more
bmxhacksaw said:
Don't be so hard on yourself. Maybe you're just incompetent. :)

Seriously, crashes happen, and if you don't remember a glaring error, I'd say you should just let it go.
Undecided said:
Don't be so hard on yourself. Maybe you're just incompetent. :)
I think I prefer the former. :)
perfect illustration! :thumbsup:
none of those lines is a friendly crit line if riders are in anything other than single file. The lime green is what most will try to perform but it will eventually chop the inside riders if you are 2 or more abreast. Friendly is sweeping the corner in your same position as your lane position. Often the front guy will "apex" the corner with the rest "holding their line"
also, don't fret the crash ... buy a beer, discuss, learn, move on
Travis said:
none of those lines is a friendly crit line if riders are in anything other than single file. The lime green is what most will try to perform but it will eventually chop the inside riders if you are 2 or more abreast. Friendly is sweeping the corner in your same position as your lane position. Often the front guy will "apex" the corner with the rest "holding their line"
i think we understand that, it's just the general concept of an apex that is being explained. i don't know about you, but i spend plenty of time in crits pretty much single file...obviously if it isn't single file, you follow the wheels...not much else you can do.
Update

The guy that went down showed up (in a sling) to the ride last night. I had sent him a letter expressing my regret in having been involved in the situation and he knows my email address yet had not responded so I was concerned that he was holding onto anger over the incident or something but he's all cool with it. He said that's racing and stuff happens.

The interesting thing is that he has a markedly different take on what transpired. I maintain that I came up the right side of the pack and that contact was made just as we started to enter the right-hander at the end of the front straight. He claims that we were about 50 yards from the corner traveling in a straight line and that I did not hold my line and that my rear derailleur went into his front wheel. He says he has it on video.

Very interesting since my derailleur is fine and all the missing spokes on my rear wheel are on the non-drive side of the wheel. Do you think the trauma/impact of the crash has distorted what he recalls?
See less See more
bmxhacksaw said:
The guy that went down showed up (in a sling) to the ride last night. I had sent him a letter expressing my regret in having been involved in the situation and he knows my email address yet had not responded so I was concerned that he was holding onto anger over the incident or something but he's all cool with it. He said that's racing and stuff happens.

The interesting thing is that he has a markedly different take on what transpired. I maintain that I came up the right side of the pack and that contact was made just as we started to enter the right-hander at the end of the front straight. He claims that we were about 50 yards from the corner traveling in a straight line and that I did not hold my line and that my rear derailleur went into his front wheel. He says he has it on video.

Very interesting since my derailleur is fine and all the missing spokes on my rear wheel are on the non-drive side of the wheel. Do you think the trauma/impact of the crash has distorted what he recalls?
Dood your taking all of this waaaay too far! It was a crash, they happen in most every race be it crit, road race whatever they happen all of the time. Racers crash, thats why racers are such [email protected]' and century riders are old hairy fat dudes with helmet mirrors and sweaty bar tape.

I've been in a lot of races where I could'nt clearly remember who I was pissed at 30 seconds later. People look different in their kit both on the bike and off, teammates look similar, other kits look similar, and when your racing your brain (at least mine is) is not working properly. I cannot focus on specific details of what a kit says or what a rider looks like in a race unless I really concentrate on them for some reason like they are reeeaaallly squirly. Most of the time everyones recollection is fuzzy, if he is'nt pissed then awesome. Shake hands, tell him you'll buy him a coffee or a beer or something, and move on. After all next week it may be you wearing the sling... thats just racing and if you plan to stay a racer you must accept it for what it ultimately is... fun and dangerous.
See less See more
One of my teammates directed me here and I guess I feel compelled to respond now.

Seriously, K, you've got to just let this go. Questioning my recollection is plain silly. I told you last night that things happen in racing and all I wanted was for you to realize what happened and to learn from it.

As the guy that got taken out, I had a really good perspective at what happened (better than anyone). And, last time I checked, you didn't have eyes in the back of your head. Frankly, I am not sure you even knew you took me out when you did. I would venture to guess that when you moved out, you took out my wheel and then moved forward to the front of the race (of course, I could be wrong because at this point I was curled up in a ball trying to avoid additional riders running over me).

The fact of the matter is that I was on the ground, directly parallel to my wife and family which was about 30-50 meters before the corner, still in the straight leading up to turn one. If your really feel the need I can have you talk to all of them too. But, I was fully conscious and the medical personnel helped me walk over to the corner where the med tent was. I had no head injuries, so to question what I recall, i.e., lived, is plain ridiculous.

If I'm being completely candid, just recognize you made a mistake by not holding your line. Don't do it again. Keep riding and learning. Of course you never want to take out a friend, but sometimes it happens. I am over it and you need to move on, I have. Rehashing it is silly and does nothing to help you move on from any mental scars you may have. It is not the first time I've gone down and likely is not the last. Like my coach always says, when you are racing it is not if you are going to go down, it is when.

The good news is I was able to ride for about a 1/2 hour on my trainer last night, albeit very slowly and without much power. My off-season started earlier than I anticipated but its all good. It's an inconvinience but could have been a lot worse.

Stop beating yourself up and feeling like you need so validation about what happened. I think you have done what you can and just need to move on and ride.

nuff said.

NRS
See less See more
Thanks for the response N. As I said in my letter I don't want to be the cause of injury to someone and If you read my post about the incident on my blog you will see that it caused me a great deal of grief that I was a part of it. The reason that I brought it back up is that I'm supposed to learn from my mistake and now there is a completely different version of what I thought happened. I can't learn from it if I don't have a clear understanding of what went on. So now I'm left with am I really that lame of a rider that I can't hold my line going straight? Should I even be on the course if this is the case? Now I'm more confused than before.
21 - 40 of 44 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top