Road Bike, Cycling Forums banner
1 - 16 of 16 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,108 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I have owned this bike for about 8 mnths or so.

I bought the frame after my custom steel Chas Roberts died in an accident and I couldn't wait 6 mnths for another so nabbed this frame. Shame as it'd only just been resprayed.

The kit is a mix of 2/3/4 yr old Campagnolo Record. Training wheels are 32/32 Chorus hubs laced to CXP33's. The steerer needs taking down about 1.5-2cm but been too lazy to get it sorted as I ride a heap of other bikes too (I prefer retro steel - see my latest over on the retro forum).

Last November I rode this in a 160km (100m) sportif event and did it in 4.31 and found the bike really comfortable. Not bad for an old gimmer!!! No stunning ride qualities one way or t'other. It's set up like most of my other bikes and rides like them - well!!!

It's a lovely metallic silver, burnt orange and black. Tyres don't go, but hey. Not sure what it weighs, maybe 17lbs. Frame isn't light I recall it being in the region of c1100g and the fork about 350g. Bicycling gave it a good write up (not why I bought it).

I've tried to show the rather different tube profiles.

Hope you like.:p

DannyBoy.
 

·
Lost in the Black Hills
Joined
·
189 Posts
awesome!

i have been drooling over geneo's for a couple yrs now. i will most likely be getting one.

you don't think it is anything great? do you think it would be much better than an ibis silk? or just the fact that it is custom built will make it better than a silk?

i am pretty short. about 5'4" with 30 inseam and always thought i would especially benefit from a custom frame....maybe more so than others.

mx
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,108 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
No no, don't get me wrong...........

mx_599 said:
you don't think it is anything great? do you think it would be much better than an ibis silk? or just the fact that it is custom built will make it better than a silk?
No, it's great, it'sjust that retro inspired stuff gets me going more. A few of my other rides below will explain why I don't/didn't get too excited by this.

I think the Ibis is a good bike too, I looked at them and they got good reviews, this won on colour and idividuality.

Also I often think bike reviews that talk about lateral stiffness and vertical compliance etc are a load of bollox. I can't tell most bikes from each other if set up the same - probably a failing on my part, or is fit more important than material!!!!

I guess I was saying it's set up in a similar way to my other steel bikes and as such rides just like 'em - well.

It is a nice bike. It was great to race on, but when I ain't racing I'm on retro steel.

If carbon floats your boat you'll like this...............:thumbsup:
 

·
Lost in the Black Hills
Joined
·
189 Posts
DannyBoy said:
No, it's great, it'sjust that retro inspired stuff gets me going more. A few of my other rides below will explain why I don't/didn't get too excited by this.

I think the Ibis is a good bike too, I looked at them and they got good reviews, this won on colour and idividuality.

Also I often think bike reviews that talk about lateral stiffness and vertical compliance etc are a load of bollox. I can't tell most bikes from each other if set up the same - probably a failing on my part, or is fit more important than material!!!!

:
i am only about 135lbs. most bikes will be stiff enough for me i would guess. it would seem that the ibis might be able to be built lighter. i wanted a pretty light frame when i build up my nice road bike.

but i am thinking i should have a custom frame because of my height. i wonder if up coming geneo's will be put on a diet...slightly different design? i am probably a good year away from getting one. i am thinking a 2009 model.

with top components i am sure it could be built around 16 lbs. do you think someone of my size should shoot for 15lbs?

thanks

mx
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,108 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
mx_599 said:
i am only about 135lbs. most bikes will be stiff enough for me i would guess. it would seem that the ibis might be able to be built lighter. i wanted a pretty light frame when i build up my nice road bike.

but i am thinking i should have a custom frame because of my height. i wonder if up coming geneo's will be put on a diet...slightly different design? i am probably a good year away from getting one. i am thinking a 2009 model.

with top components i am sure it could be built around 16 lbs. do you think someone of my size should shoot for 15lbs?

thanks

mx
Well here's a few things to think about.

Firstly I don't think Guru do a true custom build. I think they have a few standardised options, but I don't think you can have a huge amount of customisation.

Second, you're right about the Ibis, I looked and thought about it for the same reasons. I really only bought the Geneo because it looked nice to me, most other carbon is a bit dull in my opinion. It reminded me of a similarly shaped Look.

If you want a true custom and something that will last I'd really really think long and hard about getting a proper custom built and fitted steel or Ti frame.

And if you don't think a steel bike can be light look at this guys S&S coupled Roberts (I've actually picked this up when it was in Roberts showroom and was flabergasted at how light it was). 12lbs and change. Do take a look at the link;

http://www.sandsmachine.com/a_rob_r5.htm

Just took the Geneo out for a nice 40km lunchtime ride, nice bike. I still prefered my custom steel Roberts that died in a crash and made way for the Geneo.
 

·
Lost in the Black Hills
Joined
·
189 Posts
DannyBoy said:
Well here's a few things to think about.

Firstly I don't think Guru do a true custom build. I think they have a few standardised options, but I don't think you can have a huge amount of customisation..
thanks, i will consider what you say for sure.

however, are you sure the geneo is not custom? i thought that was the whole point. this is the main reason i wanted it. i will be disappointed if it is not like a custom Ti or steel frame.

now i am bummed out. custom measured frame was the whole reason i got excited about the guru geneo :confused:

mx
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,108 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
mx_599 said:
thanks, i will consider what you say for sure.

however, are you sure the geneo is not custom? i thought that was the whole point. this is the main reason i wanted it. i will be disappointed if it is not like a custom Ti or steel frame.

now i am bummed out. custom measured frame was the whole reason i got excited about the guru geneo :confused:

mx
Irace you. Let's both check their website. I haven't looked for ages.

As an aside look at this other post about frame materials, steel fairs quite well (and you ain't goin' to see catastrophic failures like that with steel that often);

http://forums.roadbikereview.com/showthread.php?t=136399
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,108 Posts
Discussion Starter · #15 ·
Hey I just read all the marketing crap........

...........turns out I bought something flash..................surely having read all that I'll be going faster on tomorrows lunchtime ride! Ha Ha:thumbsup:
 
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top