Road Bike, Cycling Forums banner
1 - 20 of 50 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,841 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Judge finds Michelle Carter guilty of manslaughter in texting suicide case - CNN.com

Seriously yo, it was a case involving 2 teens who were both depressed and taking psychotic medications at the time. And anyone who has ever lived thru the teenage years will know that this is when we tend to do and say stupid things while we're "normal". Now mix in depression and medication you have trouble.

My question is, where were the boy's parents in all this? He obviously had a suicidal tenacity beforehand, why didn't the parents get him help?

So if I give some guy a bicycle and urge him to ride over a cliff and he did and killed himself, am I guilty for his behavior and/or stupidity?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,709 Posts
Beyond ridiculous.

It'll be interesting to see what the sentence is. She was tried as a juvenile even though she isn't at this time. Hopefully she gets a very light sentence. Still, with a felony on her record, her future is screwed.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
20,820 Posts
But it was more than just texting him to kill himself.

She encouraged him to get back in the truck to finish killing himself. And she was listening on the phone as he was dying and did nothing. She could have stopped it or at the least called 911.

So if I give some guy a bicycle and urge him to ride over a cliff and he did and killed himself, am I guilty for his behavior and/or stupidity?
If he rode over the cliff but was still alive and then you did nothing while watching him die... yea you'd be guilty.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,658 Posts
So if I give some guy a bicycle and urge him to ride over a cliff and he did and killed himself, am I guilty for his behavior and/or stupidity?
If you knew that guy had a disease that made your expected expected result him actually doing it and it wouldn't have happened but for you, yeah, you'd be guilty of the same thing.

I'm definitely no legal expert but initiating something you know will end in death sounds like a pretty clear cut case to me.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,841 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
I wonder how the boy's parents feel in all this?
Are they feeling vindicated that the girl gets to go to jail?
Or are they feeling guilty because they did a shitty taking care of their kid?

It would not surprise me if his parents felt vindicated for their own lack of parental responsibility. Ridiculous
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,841 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
If you knew that guy had a disease that made your expected expected result him actually doing it and it wouldn't have happened but for you, yeah, you'd be guilty of the same thing.

I'm definitely no legal expert but initiating something you know will end in death sounds like a pretty clear cut case to me.
Dude you ever seen those extreme Red Bulls videos on mtb freeride or motox stunts? That's like asking young me to risk their lives, and yes a few have died doing it. All for some money. And one can argue that the enticement of money can also be used as device to entice a person to his death.

The boy knew he was about to kill himself if he inhaled the carbon monoxide. He was intelligent enough to know. He was intelligent to get the f* out of the truck, but then he was dumb enough to get back in. That's just self mutilating. He ain't a mentally retarded person, in which case it would be be more clear cut.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
20,820 Posts
Dude you ever seen those extreme Red Bulls videos on mtb freeride or motox stunts? That's like asking young me to risk their lives, and yes a few have died doing it. All for some money. And one can argue that the enticement of money can also be used as device to entice a person to his death.
One could argue that, but they'd be wrong. The purpose of those stunts isn't to KILL themselves.

And again.... if someone were injured doing one of those stunts, and then people sat and watched them die, they'd be guilty. Odd, you keep skipping over that part.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,658 Posts
Dude you ever seen those extreme Red Bulls videos on mtb freeride or motox stunts? That's like asking young me to risk their lives, and yes a few have died doing it. All for some money. And one can argue that the enticement of money can also be used as device to entice a person to his death.

The boy knew he was about to kill himself if he inhaled the carbon monoxide. He was intelligent enough to know. He was intelligent to get the f* out of the truck, but then he was dumb enough to get back in. That's just self mutilating. He ain't a mentally retarded person, in which case it would be be more clear cut.
No I haven't seen those videos.

Intelligence and dumb have nothing to do with the disease of depression. I'm certainly no expert on depression either but your understanding is about 100 years behind. Facilitating action where the expected result is death due to a disease sounds wrong to me. Not you apparently.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,580 Posts
Dude you ever seen those extreme Red Bulls videos on mtb freeride or motox stunts? That's like asking young me to risk their lives, and yes a few have died doing it. All for some money. And one can argue that the enticement of money can also be used as device to entice a person to his death.

The boy knew he was about to kill himself if he inhaled the carbon monoxide. He was intelligent enough to know. He was intelligent to get the f* out of the truck, but then he was dumb enough to get back in. That's just self mutilating. He ain't a mentally retarded person, in which case it would be be more clear cut.

This has nothing to do with what happened in this case.

Encouraging someone (by paying them) to do a stunt, regardless of how dangerous it is, is a LOT different than encouraging a depressed person to kill themselves, and giving them the specific procedures to do it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,841 Posts
Discussion Starter · #12 ·
so while the judge blasted the girl, who herself was taking psychotic related medication, for the act, I feel the root of this problem for the boy started way earlier and back at home with the parents. If the kid was retarted, that's different. From what I can see, he was just a regular teenager, who was probably negleted by his parents, and turned depresses and probably took some drugs, and met an equally depressed g/f who goad him on to suicide. The guy voluntarily knew he was killing himself. He was cognitive of this fact, was he not? Time to man up and stop the pussified bucking kicking.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
20,820 Posts
From what I can see, he was just a regular teenager, who was probably negleted by his parents, and turned depresses and probably took some drugs, and met an equally depressed g/f who goad him on to suicide.
And... yet again... you leave out the part where she sat there and did nothing while he was dying.
So odd.

You obviously have little experience in depression, drugs, and suicide.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,830 Posts
What she did was reprehensible, but not murder, of which manslaughter is a version.

"The unjustifiable, inexcusable, and intentional killing of a human being without deliberation, premeditation, and malice. The unlawful killing of a human being without any deliberation, which may be involuntary, in the commission of a lawful act without due caution and circumspection."

She had no hand in the physical act that resulted in the boys death, thus I am just not seeing how they can find her guilty of this.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,658 Posts
What she did was reprehensible, but not murder, of which manslaughter is a version.

"The unjustifiable, inexcusable, and intentional killing of a human being without deliberation, premeditation, and malice. The unlawful killing of a human being without any deliberation, which may be involuntary, in the commission of a lawful act without due caution and circumspection."

She had no hand in the physical act that resulted in the boys death, thus I am just not seeing how they can find her guilty of this.
you might want to look at the definition you posted a little closer, because it says nothing about physical. But it does say "without due caution and circumspection". You think egging on a depressed person to kill them self exhibits caution and circumspection?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,488 Posts
Dude you ever seen those extreme Red Bulls videos on mtb freeride or motox stunts? That's like asking young me to risk their lives, and yes a few have died doing it. All for some money. And one can argue that the enticement of money can also be used as device to entice a person to his death.
I'm not getting into the argument regarding whether or not the girl should have been found guilty but that example is not even close to applying in this situation. The people getting paid to do those stunts are already doing those stunts. They've been doing them for a long time without getting paid while they tried to get good enough to get paid. They're not enticed (at least, no more than any of us are enticed to do our job by the money we receive for doing it), it's their chosen career path. They know the inherent risk attached to their chosen career and decided their skill level is such that the risk is outweighed by the reward.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,830 Posts
Similar to, can a gang leader who orders a rival killed, be tried for murder ?, don't know.

I do think that a definition of killing, typically might require physical involvement by the so called killer. I've no clue as to case law on this.
 

·
Pathlete and Pedalphile
Joined
·
3,181 Posts
Similar to, can a gang leader who orders a rival killed, be tried for murder ?, don't know.

I do think that a definition of killing, typically might require physical involvement by the so called killer. I've no clue as to case law on this.
If you are just the getaway driver in a robbery and your partner kills the victim, you will be tried for murder too.
 

·
Not Banned
Joined
·
49,013 Posts
read the transcripts. She was encouraging him to di it. He was apologizing to her for not doing it already. She talked him back into gassing himself, was in communique with him while he was dying and didn't call for someone to help or stop him.
When your actions are directly responsible for someones death, manslaughter is what they give you.
The kid got out of the car, he had second thoughts. He returned to his death on her advice. That was the crux of the conviction
She got what she deserved.
 
1 - 20 of 50 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top